The American Idolater

What’s everyone’s problem with Carly Smithson? The front page of yahoo.com (I kid you not) reads:
Unfair ‘Idol’ eliminations?
“Idol” eliminates four, but controversial Carly survives the cut.
That takes you to an AP story about the Idol eliminations, where apparently the big story is that Carly stayed on the show no matter how “unfair” that was [...]

Welcome back everyone! Time for a new season! I don’t know if that’s a good thing or a bad thing. I guess we have to wait and see.
But for starters, was I the only one who felt like most of the bad singers last night were completely fake, and were just trying [...]